I got into Trek at the age of seventeen, when TNG was in its fifth season. Contrary to most of the people my age, I actually preferred The Original Series, but I also quite enjoyed The Next Generation. I had a lukewarm relationship with Deep Space Nine and eventually drifted away, as my attempts to be captured by Voyager never bore fruit. So I've been away from the franchise since about 1996, I'm afraid. Never even tried Enterprise.

Personally, I think that they should jump another generation and try again. It was 21 years from the launch of TOS (1966) to TNG (1987) and it has been 23 from the TNG launch to present. Why not jump forward another hundred years and see if it would breathe new life into the franchise?